legends · 4 min read ·
Eleven Minutes of Silence
A podcast about a vanished hill town reveals the eleven minutes each day when the town counts itself.
**Podcast: Where the Road Ends — Episode 47: Hollin, Pennsylvania**
*Host: Dev Rahimi. Guest: Marguerite Vance, former county surveyor.*
*Transcript auto-generated. Some segments inaudible.*
· · ·
**DEV:** Welcome back. This is the episode a lot of you asked for. Hollin is a town in the hills, about ninety people at the last census, and it was taken off the state highway map in 1971. You can still find it in old atlases. You can't find it on a modern GPS. Marguerite worked for the county for twenty-two years, and she was the last person to survey it.
**MARGUERITE:** I went up there in March of 1998 to re-mark a boundary. There was a church, a feed store, a row of houses on Cedar Lane. The people were friendly. They fed me supper and asked after my mother.
**DEV:** Did anything strike you as odd?
**MARGUERITE:** Everything was on time. That's what I remember. The clock in the feed store was right. The bread in the bakery was still warm when I came in, and it was ten in the morning. The whole town ran as if somebody had set it to a timetable and nobody dared change the setting.
**DEV:** And the silence?
**MARGUERITE:** [pause] I'd like to talk about that part carefully.
· · ·
*[00:14:20 — segment transcribed from listener recording, recorded by a member of the Hollin Historical Society. Contributed anonymously.]*
They called it the eleven minutes. Every afternoon at 15:00 the town stopped. Not the clocks. The sound. The traffic on the county road went silent, the dogs stopped, the birds went quiet in the cedars. The people kept walking, but nobody spoke for eleven minutes, and when it ended they resumed as if nothing had happened.
My grandmother said it was the town's way of listening. I asked what they were listening for. She said, "The number of people who are supposed to be here."
· · ·
**DEV:** Marguerite, you say you stayed.
**MARGUERITE:** I stayed for the eleven minutes. I wanted to know what the silence was for. I sat on the bench outside the feed store with my notebook open. At three o'clock the sound went out of the air like a lid coming down on a pot.
I counted. I can't help counting. I was counting the people on the street. There were eleven of them, including me, and the eleven minutes started.
I counted again, to be sure. Twelve.
**DEV:** Twelve?
**MARGUERITE:** There was a woman standing at the end of the bench who hadn't been there a second before. She had a brown coat and a basket on her arm, and she was looking at me the way you'd look at a neighbor who'd come to supper without knocking.
I didn't speak. Nobody spoke. And when I looked back, she was still there, and I could hear my own breath very clearly, and I could hear hers, two seconds behind mine, counting along.
**DEV:** What did you do?
**MARGUERITE:** I looked at my watch. I wanted to know how long the eleven minutes had left. The hands were stopped at 15:00, and under the glass, somebody had scratched a small mark, a tally. One stroke. And then, while I watched, a second stroke appeared beside it, very fine, as if a fingernail had made it from the inside.
**DEV:** Marguerite, did you leave Hollin that day?
**MARGUERITE:** [inaudible]
· · ·
**Listener message, 6 days ago:**
I was in Hollin last month. I didn't hear the eleven minutes. I heard the number. It was said by a voice that sounded like the woman in the brown coat. Someone was counting the people on Cedar Lane. The count was higher than the houses.
**Listener message, 4 days ago:**
I went back to see if I could find the bench. It's gone. There's a clean square of gravel where it used to be, and a small brass plate set in the middle, very old. It says "Hollin, 1971" and under that, in a newer hand: "Thirteen."
**Listener message, 2 days ago:**
Dev, I'm not from Hollin. I'm from the county survey office, and I found Marguerite's notebook in our archive last week. The last entry is from the afternoon of the eleven minutes. She wrote the count in the margin. Eleven. Then she crossed it out. Then she wrote twelve. Then, underneath, in a smaller hand that I think is hers: *The number is always the one we forgot to say aloud.*
· · ·
**DEV:** Marguerite, we're almost out of time. Is there anything you want listeners to know before they go looking for Hollin?
**MARGUERITE:** [long pause] Don't sit on the bench at three. Don't count the people you can see. The silence isn't for the town. It's for the one who's standing at the end of the bench, and it only lasts while you're listening to yourself breathe.
**DEV:** And if you hear the eleven minutes starting?
**MARGUERITE:** Then you're already in the count, and you'd better stop counting, and walk. Walk away from the bench. Don't look back at the bakery. The bread is still warm, and somebody will ask you to stay for supper.
**DEV:** Marguerite, thank you.
**MARGUERITE:** [inaudible]
*[Recording ends at 00:31:07. Listener logs indicate the recording continued for eleven minutes of silence after the host's final word.]*